75th Founding Day Lecture Meeting on “India@2030” Know More

June 2016

Appeal to High Court- Section 260A- Competency of appeal- Decision of Tribunal following earlier decision- No appeal from earlier decision- No affidavit explaining reasons: Appeal not competent-

By K. B. Bhujle
Adovcate
Reading Time 1 mins
fiogf49gjkf0d
CIT vs. Gujarat Reclaim and Rubber Products Ltd..; 383 ITR 236 (Bom):

Dealing with the competency of the Appeal before the High Court u/s. 160A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the Bombay High Court held as under:

“i) Where the issue in controversy stands settled by decisions of High Courts or the Tribunal in any other case and the Department has accepted that decision the Department ought not to agitate the issue further unless there is some cogent justification such as change in law or some later decision of a higher forum.

ii) In such cases appropriately the appeal memo itself must specify the reason for preferring an appeal failing which at least before admission the officer concerned should file an affidavit pointing out the reasons for filing the appeal. It is only when the court is satisfied with the reasons given, that the merits of the issue need be examined of purposes of admission.”

Download PDF

You May Also Like

Appeal to Appellate Tribunal- No appearance by assessee’s counsel on date of hearing due to death in family- Refusal by Tribunal to grant adjournment and matter decided on merits: Violation of principles of natural justice- Order of Tribunal quashed and direction to decide matter on merits after hearing parties-

Capital gains- Transfer- S/s. 45(1), (4) – A. Y. 1992- 93- Conversion of firm to company- Takeover of business of firm with assets by private limited company with same partners as shareholders in same proportion: Subsequent revaluation of assets- No dissolution of partnership- No consideration accrued or received on transfer of assets: Transaction not transfer giving rise to capital gains-